Kataifi Cheese Pie

This kataifi cheese pie recipe unites kataifi pastry with several kinds of cheese for a Greek-inspired pie dish that will wow your dinner guests.

16 servings
2 hrs 10 mins
327 kcal
NF VE

When it comes to the beloved Greek household, pies come first and kataifi pastry comes second! Kataifi is a lightly sweetened shredded filo dough widely used in Greece, often notably seen as ‘kadayif‘ in Middle Eastern desserts – you might have tasted this in some baklava varieties without even knowing it! Despite kataifi’s subtle sweetness and tendency towards being more of a dessert, Greeks love using it for savory pies and other delicious dishes. It’s no secret that kataifi takes any savory pie up a notch, bringing out deeper flavors and giving dishes a unique texture like nowhere else.

If you’re looking for a dish to steal the show at your next gathering, kataifi pastry is the ingredient you need! This recipe puts kataifi filo pastry nests to work in giving a unique spin on both traditional Hellenic pie and kataifi. With several varieties of melt-in-the-mouth cheese tucked into these nests and then baked in a pie dish, you get a rich filling with a light, crispy texture that will be sure to leave everyone wanting more. Be warned - this tasty treat is so irresistibly scrumptious that it may just cause a scene when it hits the table!

Everyone loves a special dish that requires time and effort, but let’s be honest - who has the time? Kataifi pastry may not be available everywhere, but thankfully you don’t have to send out a search party to locate it! Greek delis, online, and even some larger grocery stores carry kataifi pastry so you can get started on your cheese kataifi pie right away. Forgo the labor of creating the pastry from scratch and spoil your guests with this delicious dinner in no time. The result will be nothing short of spectacular - just make sure you save a piece for yourself!

Recipe Video Get Cooking Share Tweet Pin

Tips

After your delectable pie is baked to perfection, let it sit for a bit. This will give the flavors time to meld together and each layer an opportunity to crisp up nicely prior to serving.

Baking times may vary depending on oven type and size, so check regularly while baking until there is a golden brown color on top of the crust.

Keep your kataifi cheese pie fresh by storing it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two days.

Directions

You will need about 2 hours 10 minutes to make 16 servings of this recipe, which has approximately 327 calories each. Make sure you have all the ingredients and follow these 8 simple steps. If you have any questions, send me an email and I’d be more than happy to help!

Gently whisk together 3 eggs, pepper, and all of the cheeses (feta, Roquefort, cheddar, and gouda) in a bowl until fully combined.

Prepare the kataifi pastry by pulling it apart, and gently spreading its strands out until it is light and airy.

Utilize a small bowl to craft each pie by combining a generous portion of kataifi pastry and an ample spoonful of cheese filling.

Carefully roll each portion into a ball before transferring it to an oiled baking tray. Continue repeating the process until all of your delicious dough is shaped and on the tray!

Gently melt the butter, then evenly spread it over each pie for irresistible flavor and texture.

In a bowl, whisk the remaining 3 eggs with double cream, and milk until smooth. Pour the mixture evenly over your tray for even distribution.

Place the kataifi in the refrigerator for half an hour to soak up all of the flavors from the egg mixture.

Fire up your oven to 180º C (350º F) and bake for approximately 50 minutes or until the top is a beautiful golden color.

Watch it step-by-step!